Controversial film about Hitler and Goebbels collapses the distance of decades (2024)

Table of Contents
Leader and Seducer confronts audiences with the crimes of their bystander ancestors as Germany’s current political climate becomes unsettled The past is never far away in Georgia despite the relentless focus on America’s future Donald Trump pledges ‘new golden age’ for America as son of New York takes over the Garden ‘For them, the Soviet past is something to protect’: History a political battleground in Stalin’s homeland IN THIS SECTION Thousands protest in Georgia against election outcome as opposition groups refuse to accept defeat What did the Romans ever do in Narbonne? A magnificent new museum sheds light on 500 years of history ‘Blatant fraud’: Georgia’s opposition calls for protests over election result The Ukrainian female commander fighting Putin’s forces: ‘If I have to choose between death and captivity, I will choose death’ European asylum policy continues to shift to the right ‘There are times I regret having kids. They’re adults, and it’s now that I’m regretting it, which seems strange’ ‘Early mornings worked best. I was at my desk at 4.30am’: How I got 9H1s in the Leaving Cert A forgotten deal, a €2.5m tax rebate: How Irish tycoon's ‘worrying’ conduct kept him in bankruptcy Irish couple’s €6,500 dream holiday ruined after Emirates staff spot this minor blemish on passport Bankrupt property tycoon Derek Quinlan gave undeclared €2.5m tax refund to his wife Live from the GPO – Brendan Balfe on making waves at Radio Éireann Graham Rowntree parts company with Munster PwC profits fall in Asia after scandals in China and Australia Is the Manchester United job too big a risk for Rúben Amorim? ‘No alternative to Unrwa’: UN chief calls on Israel not to ban and criminalise Palestinian aid Democrats make final campaign push amid fallout from Puerto Rico ‘joke’ at Trump rally Trump 2.0 would be fascism tempered by senility What is Unrwa and why has Israel’s parliament voted to ban it? References

Europe

Leader and Seducer confronts audiences with the crimes of their bystander ancestors as Germany’s current political climate becomes unsettled

Controversial film about Hitler and Goebbels collapses the distance of decades (1)

Controversial film about Hitler and Goebbels collapses the distance of decades (2)

Derek Scally in Berlin

Fri Jul 12 2024 - 16:00

In the darkened Berlin cinema, the first voice to speak sounds like a friendly Austrian country priest.

That this is the regular – utterly unrecognisable – speaking voice of Adolf Hitler, in a secret recording from 1942, is the final triumph of Joseph Goebbels.

This is the provocative opening pitch of the new German film Führer und Verführer (Leader and Seducer): Nazi Germany may have lost the second World War but Goebbels won key propaganda battles.

Actor Robert Stadlober, in a relentless and restless performance as the great Nazi seducer, asks early on: “Does anyone know who Stalin’s propaganda chief is, or Churchill’s? Everyone knows who Goebbels is.”

READ MORE

The past is never far away in Georgia despite the relentless focus on America’s future

Donald Trump pledges ‘new golden age’ for America as son of New York takes over the Garden

‘For them, the Soviet past is something to protect’: History a political battleground in Stalin’s homeland

Eight decades after his suicide, this hack turned spindoctor remains a household name. But few realise how effective he was in transforming Hitler from beer-hall bellower into a master of the airwaves, captivating Germans with devastating results.

Controversial film about Hitler and Goebbels collapses the distance of decades (6)

Nearly 80 years on from the last days of the Nazis, documented 20 years ago in the groundbreaking film Downfall, this new demagoguery drama has a wider focus. And it opens in a different, unsettled Germany.

After spending decades – and millions – on historical research and public education, the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) sits in the Bundestag in Berlin – and all 16 state parliaments.

This is the party whose former leader described the Nazi era as “bird s**t in more than 1,000 years of successful German history”. The party that, come September, may win 30 per cent support in three eastern states.

Months after The Zone of Interest took an abstract, arthouse approach to Auschwitz, Führer und Verführer is, by comparison, a cinematic fire axe.

It is not subtle but, judging by the shocked silence at the Berlin premiere on Thursday night, it is brutally effective, exhaustive and, at times, exhausting.

The question of how this could happen is not part of our past but our present. We are living in a time where far-right populists are on the rise and anti-Semitic crimes and the Third Reich are trivialised

— Joachim A Lang, director and screenwriter

Original propaganda footage is mixed with making-of scenes and juxtaposed with fictional private scenes. First-person Holocaust survivor testimony interrupts the drama while, in a final gut punch, viewers are shown footage of actual shootings, hangings and other Nazi atrocities. Collapsing the distance of decades is intentional.

“The question of how this could happen is not part of our past but our present,” said Joachim A Lang, director and screenwriter, at the premiere. “We are living in a time where far-right populists are on the rise and anti-Semitic crimes and the Third Reich are trivialised.”

His show-don’t-tell approach is a conscious – and controversial – pushback against Germany’s decades-old norm of prioritising the survivor/victim perspective.

But, for some, the film’s “seduction” approach carries uncomfortable memories of the postwar years, when Germans shrugged off responsibility with the argument: it wasn’t me, it was Hitler.

“The greatest failure of this film,” argued Der Spiegel magazine, “is that it largely excludes the seduced.”

For Lang, this was a risk worth taking. After decades of holding up a mirror to the German population – with mixed results – he confronts audiences with the actual crimes of their bystander ancestors, and the real charm of their criminal leaders.

“Showing all these figures as screaming brawlers doesn’t show why our parents and grandparents fell for them,” said Lang.

For German historian Thomas Weber, based at the University of Aberdeen and a consultant on the film, the current emotional domestic debate over what is permissible in a Hitler film is just more German hand-wringing that misses the wood for the trees.

“We are living in a new era of misinformation and demagogues,” he said, “and surely looking at the last war would help us understand better the conditions and mechanisms that led to that war, and how similar they are to what we are seeing today.”

With a remarkable attention to detail – make-up, lighting and clever editing – Lang finds a back door to recreate and deconstruct the original Nazi propaganda – and its mastermind.

His Goebbels enjoys the challenge of maintaining poll ratings despite Hitler’s dithering and contradictory policies. Hammering home repetitive messages of hate and fear, the big-screen Goebbels could be talking about today’s small-screen social media when he likens propaganda to a painting: “It’s not the size that counts but the emotional impact.”

Even Hitler actor Fritz Karl, at times an eerie dictator doppelgänger, admits: “With the right advertising, any fool can take power.”

[How to Win an Information War by Peter Pomerantsev: A vital lesson in dangerous propagandaOpens in new window]

In this era of political fools, extremes and shocks, Thursday’s premiere audience needed a moment to catch their breath after more than two hours of bombardment.

For Chris Ahnert, a 32-year-old teacher who works with young offenders, taking the perpetrator perspective is a risky but timely approach.

“Increasingly in Germany we have young people who don’t want to engage with this,” he said, “and families not prepared to even admit what happened, that our families were part of this.”

Also in the audience was Georg Friedrich Prinz von Preussen, head of the house of Hohenzollern and great-great-grandson of Wilhelm II, Germany’s last Kaiser.

“This film is painful but necessary,” he said. “People didn’t fall for demons but for other, charming people.”

Decades after postwar Germany adopted “never again” as its motto, this film’s uncomfortable warning is: never say never again.

[In a Word... SeductionOpens in new window]

  • Sign up for push alerts and have the best news, analysis and comment delivered directly to your phone
  • Find The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date
  • Our In The News podcast is now published daily – Find the latest episode here

GermanyAdolf Hitler

IN THIS SECTION

Thousands protest in Georgia against election outcome as opposition groups refuse to accept defeat

What did the Romans ever do in Narbonne? A magnificent new museum sheds light on 500 years of history

‘Blatant fraud’: Georgia’s opposition calls for protests over election result

The Ukrainian female commander fighting Putin’s forces: ‘If I have to choose between death and captivity, I will choose death’

European asylum policy continues to shift to the right

MOST READ

‘There are times I regret having kids. They’re adults, and it’s now that I’m regretting it, which seems strange’

‘Early mornings worked best. I was at my desk at 4.30am’: How I got 9H1s in the Leaving Cert

A forgotten deal, a €2.5m tax rebate: How Irish tycoon's ‘worrying’ conduct kept him in bankruptcy

Irish couple’s €6,500 dream holiday ruined after Emirates staff spot this minor blemish on passport

Bankrupt property tycoon Derek Quinlan gave undeclared €2.5m tax refund to his wife

LATEST STORIES

Live from the GPO – Brendan Balfe on making waves at Radio Éireann

Graham Rowntree parts company with Munster

PwC profits fall in Asia after scandals in China and Australia

Is the Manchester United job too big a risk for Rúben Amorim?

‘No alternative to Unrwa’: UN chief calls on Israel not to ban and criminalise Palestinian aid

Democrats make final campaign push amid fallout from Puerto Rico ‘joke’ at Trump rally

Trump 2.0 would be fascism tempered by senility

What is Unrwa and why has Israel’s parliament voted to ban it?

Controversial film about Hitler and Goebbels collapses the distance of decades (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Last Updated:

Views: 6094

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Birthday: 1998-02-19

Address: 64841 Delmar Isle, North Wiley, OR 74073

Phone: +17844167847676

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: LARPing, Kitesurfing, Sewing, Digital arts, Sand art, Gardening, Dance

Introduction: My name is Amb. Frankie Simonis, I am a hilarious, enchanting, energetic, cooperative, innocent, cute, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.